Indian Motorcycle Forum banner

Hatt Lameflaw says Harley Davidson is dirivitive and owes its whole existence to Indian)

7.9K views 41 replies 20 participants last post by  Sith Life  
#1 · (Edited)
Indian first to patent an engine driven bicycle aka "motorcycle" in 1897.

First one to follows through on it and make a motorcycle in 1901. HD 2 years later.

1903 George Hendee starts a race for builders to compete, where he set the record at 56mph.

1904 the Indian dealerships were first to offer a color choice. It being "vermilion red".
HD opened its first dealer Same year.
3 years later Indian is first to trademark the brand having a color, and vermilion become "Indian red" admittedly IDK how long after HD trade marked black and orange, just know Indian came up with the idea of trademark colors in MC.

1906 Indian creates the first V-twin.
HD in 1909. In which landed HD in court for patent and copyright infringement on certain designs with in it. found not guilty, but as history now shows, we know to be true via biographies and admission of stealing parts.

1910 Indian develops a leaf spring suspension front end. A design used and copied for years after by HD.

1910 also saw the first automatic oil pump.
Swing arm rear suspension design concept used today.
(HD was still rigid, not even cylinder sprung yet)
First electric start.

1916 Indian develops the first stressed member engine/frame on the K series which becomes the preferred design philosophy for nearly every motorcycle except ANY HD...

1916 Indian plunger springs it's frames.
HD still rigid.

1920 Indian come out with the Scout. This bike leaves behind the belt driven primary drive Indian developed (that HD copied and still uses a version of today) the other models use and instead uses a new gear driven primary. A design most motorcycle makers use today. Expect HD.

1930 First to offer a "custom" option where customer could pick from as many 24 DuPont color's.

1938 an Indian MC club "the Jackpine Gypsies" puts together a race that still happens to this day in a lil town some HD folks may go to or at least have heard of called Sturgis.

Late 1940s introduced a telescoping fork. the first. Between the 2. And design concept used to this day by 99.9% of bikes. Including HD.

1950 the Chief is first bike of the 2 to use chrome plating over nickle.

In all seriousness, I could go on. But I won't. it got boring and was so one sided it became insulate as I wrote it..
Bottom line, is every single thing that is indicative to every single thing HDs beloved "heritage" prides it self on or with was started by Indian..
I don't "hate" guys like this. I pity them. guys like me (Hatt) realize that guys like that (Matt) stand on the shoulders of giants being critical of what they are blind to from up so high on those shoulders
it's easy to forget who walked us there...
I just find it much better for progress to acknowledge whats right, what true, and what's better regardless of who and push design forward. Not sit on laurels (others people's laurels?) And judge and insult those that do push forward simply because they are being passed up by progress. Doing so is much like an insult..(like is so commonly levied from that camp) it says nothing of the intended target, and volumes to the hurler of the insult....
Satire based on truth is one thing, insolence based in ignorance and a lack of appreciation of precedence and history is just an insult based in negligence, ignorance or both.
I would have never known this stuff if I wasn't insulted for years by them. I would have never known about Indian or HD history if my attention wasn't grabbed by their insults. I simply didn't pay attention as foreign rider. I was forced to attention...Thus Indian would have never sold me a bike if not for the insults forcing my research years ago, educating me to american bikes, and the history of them. I owed them thanks for developing technologies that were even on my foreign bikes, of which until I was forced to attention I didn't even realize I owed to Indian.
I learned of and appreciated Indian because of their history and HD "derivative" never ending insults to others and other makes. I then chose Indian because of their history, and their renewed progressive direction. Again, I used to not even pay attention to American bikes..
So go ahead Matt, take that silver salesman tongue and nervous forced laughter and sell some more Indians! Those that came before you will thank you! Those that want progress will too.

don't forget to smash that like button and subscribe.. thanks for watching, this is
Hatt Lameflaw.
 
#30 ·
View attachment 540780 Guess who’s fairing they copied.
That Craig Vetter feller sure had good taste in motorcycles, what with him riding a '72 Suzuki GT750J in that picture. Mine, a '76, will be here sometime in the next ten days or so, but I'll never quite look as dashing as Vetter did on that thing...he was 'dashing', ya know.

Back on topic though....I don't think either Harley or Indian copied Suzuki with this one.
 
#4 ·
True! I had a used Yamaha Maxim but almost went for the midnight special Virago I think it was. If I remember correctly they had a Maxim in midnight special as well. Who's copying who? Let's just say it. Matt's a dork who simply does not know his facts. He will stammer over his words if he meets anyone who truly knows their motorcycle history.
 
#8 ·
Haha. Loved the title and appreciate the sarcasm :)

I love motorcycle history....and airplane history, as that is a passion of mine and there are similar stories in airplane world and equally ignorant people.

Yup-- negativity drove me to do more digging and therefore in an odd way I appreciate it.

It's important to know why you know what you know!
 
#10 ·
Yamaha also had the "Special" models that had a stepped seat, "Buckhorn" handlebars and shorter mufflers. The 650 twin and the 750 triple had Special versions. Kawasaki called theirs LTDs. I had a 1982 KZ550 LTD which I bought new and kept for 5 riding seasons before selling it.
 
#11 ·
I had an XS 1100 midnight special with a triple. Loved that engine..
I also currently have a KZ Ltd 550 sitting in the shed waiting for my time, and me to decide if I'm going to chop the 6k mile bike into a rigid old school chopper, or restore..
 
#12 ·
Actually the 1100cc was a four. More or less a 750 triple with one more cylinder I guess. A guy I once worked with had an 1100 Midnight Special. He raved about it and that shaft drive.
 
#15 ·
Yep my 650 Maxim was a shaft drive too. Them went to a Honda shadow ACE 1100 also shaft drive. The chieftain is the first bike I have owned without a shaft drive. The Yamaha is still sitting in the garage.
 
#22 ·
Nice overview of Indian’s legit history! I saw Laidlaw’s video this AM and commented ... he’s jealous and knows Indian is putting out a high quality product with loads of buzz / forcing HD to compete hard. Lots of good Challenger test-ride videos from Adam Sandoval and others in motion — looks like a cool bike; can’t wait to test-ride!

Have either of you test driven the Challenger yet?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
#24 ·
The history of a lot of motorbike company's are interesting and worth a read or to watch a documentary about BUT
I think the most important thing is that it doesn't matter what you ride from a moped a Honda to a Triumph to a HD or Indian,whatever the important thing is to just jump on what you like or have and JUST RIDE, on 2 wheels we are all equal and we all want to JUST RIDE
 
#29 ·
Indian first to patent an engine driven bicycle aka "motorcycle" in 1897.

First one to follows through on it and make a motorcycle in 1901. HD 2 years later.

1903 George Hendee starts a race for builders to compete, where he set the record at 56mph.

1904 the Indian dealerships were first to offer a color choice. It being "vermilion red".
HD opened its first dealer Same year.
3 years later Indian is first to trademark the brand having a color, and vermilion become "Indian red" admittedly IDK how long after HD trade marked black and orange, just know Indian came up with the idea of trademark colors in MC.

1906 Indian creates the first V-twin.
HD in 1909. In which landed HD in court for patent and copyright infringement on certain designs with in it. found not guilty, but as history now shows, we know to be true via biographies and admission of stealing parts.

1910 Indian develops a leaf spring suspension front end. A design used and copied for years after by HD.

1910 also saw the first automatic oil pump.
Swing arm rear suspension design concept used today.
(HD was still rigid, not even cylinder sprung yet)
First electric start.

1916 Indian develops the first stressed member engine/frame on the K series which becomes the preferred design philosophy for nearly every motorcycle except ANY HD...

1916 Indian plunger springs it's frames.
HD still rigid.

1920 Indian come out with the Scout. This bike leaves behind the belt driven primary drive Indian developed (that HD copied and still uses a version of today) the other models use and instead uses a new gear driven primary. A design most motorcycle makers use today. Expect HD.

1930 First to offer a "custom" option where customer could pick from as many 24 DuPont color's.

1938 an Indian MC club "the Jackpine Gypsies" puts together a race that still happens to this day in a lil town some HD folks may go to or at least have heard of called Sturgis.

Late 1940s introduced a telescoping fork. the first. Between the 2. And design concept used to this day by 99.9% of bikes. Including HD.

1950 the Chief is first bike of the 2 to use chrome plating over nickle.

In all seriousness, I could go on. But I won't. it got boring and was so one sided it became insulate as I wrote it..
Bottom line, is every single thing that is indicative to every single thing HDs beloved "heritage" prides it self on or with was started by Indian..
I don't "hate" guys like this. I pity them. guys like me (Hatt) realize that guys like that (Matt) stand on the shoulders of giants being critical of what they are blind to from up so high on those shoulders
it's easy to forget who walked us there...
I just find it much better for progress to acknowledge whats right, what true, and what's better regardless of who and push design forward. Not sit on laurels (others people's laurels?) And judge and insult those that do push forward simply because they are being passed up by progress. Doing so is much like an insult..(like is so commonly levied from that camp) it says nothing of the intended target, and volumes to the hurler of the insult....
Satire based on truth is one thing, insolence based in ignorance and a lack of appreciation of precedence and history is just an insult based in negligence, ignorance or both.
I would have never known this stuff if I wasn't insulted for years by them. I would have never known about Indian or HD history if my attention wasn't grabbed by their insults. I simply didn't pay attention as foreign rider. I was forced to attention...Thus Indian would have never sold me a bike if not for the insults forcing my research years ago, educating me to american bikes, and the history of them. I owed them thanks for developing technologies that were even on my foreign bikes, of which until I was forced to attention I didn't even realize I owed to Indian.
I learned of and appreciated Indian because of their history and HD "derivative" never ending insults to others and other makes. I then chose Indian because of their history, and their renewed progressive direction. Again, I used to not even pay attention to American bikes..
So go ahead Matt, take that silver salesman tongue and nervous forced laughter and sell some more Indians! Those that came before you will thank you! Those that want progress will too.

don't forget to smash that like button and subscribe.. thanks for watching, this is
Hatt Lameflaw.
No doubt the “original” Indian Company was a trend setter. Time will tell if the current Polaris “Indian” which shares little with the original aside from the name and fenders will do the same. With the Challenger and the new 1200 bikes they are certainly off to a good start.
 
#31 · (Edited)
First one to follows through on it and make a motorcycle in 1901. HD 2 years later.
AUTO-BI (1900–1912) Buffalo, New York – Arguably the first production motorcycle in America, the first Auto-Bi was powered by a 442cc single designed by E. R. Thomas. In 1905. Professional rider W. C. Chadeayne set a new coast-to-coast crosscountry record of 48 days on one of these sweet machines.
Ref:
An A to Z Guide to American Motorcycles
 
#36 ·
Blah.
From the time you refer to.
Blah
Well like Matt said, there is no mechanical/technical connection between the Indian of the 1950’s back, to today’s modern “Polaris” Indian.
And many here would agree, today’s Indian’s roots seem to come from the “Victory”. Which Is very logical and not like it’s a bad thing.. It’s just a intuitive, practical continuation of a manufacturing process and business Model.[yuck]
Blah...
 
#32 ·
Indian first to patent an engine driven bicycle aka "motorcycle" in 1897.

First one to follows through on it and make a motorcycle in 1901. HD 2 years later.

1903 George Hendee starts a race for builders to compete, where he set the record at 56mph.

1904 the Indian dealerships were first to offer a color choice. It being "vermilion red".
HD opened its first dealer Same year.
3 years later Indian is first to trademark the brand having a color, and vermilion become "Indian red" admittedly IDK how long after HD trade marked black and orange, just know Indian came up with the idea of trademark colors in MC.

1906 Indian creates the first V-twin.
HD in 1909. In which landed HD in court for patent and copyright infringement on certain designs with in it. found not guilty, but as history now shows, we know to be true via biographies and admission of stealing parts.

1910 Indian develops a leaf spring suspension front end. A design used and copied for years after by HD.

1910 also saw the first automatic oil pump.
Swing arm rear suspension design concept used today.
(HD was still rigid, not even cylinder sprung yet)
First electric start.

1916 Indian develops the first stressed member engine/frame on the K series which becomes the preferred design philosophy for nearly every motorcycle except ANY HD...

1916 Indian plunger springs it's frames.
HD still rigid.

1920 Indian come out with the Scout. This bike leaves behind the belt driven primary drive Indian developed (that HD copied and still uses a version of today) the other models use and instead uses a new gear driven primary. A design most motorcycle makers use today. Expect HD.

1930 First to offer a "custom" option where customer could pick from as many 24 DuPont color's.

1938 an Indian MC club "the Jackpine Gypsies" puts together a race that still happens to this day in a lil town some HD folks may go to or at least have heard of called Sturgis.

Late 1940s introduced a telescoping fork. the first. Between the 2. And design concept used to this day by 99.9% of bikes. Including HD.

1950 the Chief is first bike of the 2 to use chrome plating over nickle.

In all seriousness, I could go on. But I won't. it got boring and was so one sided it became insulate as I wrote it..
Bottom line, is every single thing that is indicative to every single thing HDs beloved "heritage" prides it self on or with was started by Indian..
I don't "hate" guys like this. I pity them. guys like me (Hatt) realize that guys like that (Matt) stand on the shoulders of giants being critical of what they are blind to from up so high on those shoulders
it's easy to forget who walked us there...
I just find it much better for progress to acknowledge whats right, what true, and what's better regardless of who and push design forward. Not sit on laurels (others people's laurels?) And judge and insult those that do push forward simply because they are being passed up by progress. Doing so is much like an insult..(like is so commonly levied from that camp) it says nothing of the intended target, and volumes to the hurler of the insult....
Satire based on truth is one thing, insolence based in ignorance and a lack of appreciation of precedence and history is just an insult based in negligence, ignorance or both.
I would have never known this stuff if I wasn't insulted for years by them. I would have never known about Indian or HD history if my attention wasn't grabbed by their insults. I simply didn't pay attention as foreign rider. I was forced to attention...Thus Indian would have never sold me a bike if not for the insults forcing my research years ago, educating me to american bikes, and the history of them. I owed them thanks for developing technologies that were even on my foreign bikes, of which until I was forced to attention I didn't even realize I owed to Indian.
I learned of and appreciated Indian because of their history and HD "derivative" never ending insults to others and other makes. I then chose Indian because of their history, and their renewed progressive direction. Again, I used to not even pay attention to American bikes..
So go ahead Matt, take that silver salesman tongue and nervous forced laughter and sell some more Indians! Those that came before you will thank you! Those that want progress will too.

don't forget to smash that like button and subscribe.. thanks for watching, this is
Hatt Lameflaw.
From the time you refer to.
 
#33 ·
And your point is...

In 1901, a prototype and two production units of the diamond framed Indian Single were successfully designed, built and tested. The first Indian motorcycles, having chain drives and streamlined styling, were sold to the public in 1902. In 1903, Indian's co-founder and chief engineer Oscar Hedstrom set the world motorcycle speed record of 56 mph.[citation needed] In 1904 the company introduced the deep red color that would become Indian's trademark. Annual production of Indian motorcycles then exceeded 500, rising to a peak of 32,000 in 1913.
 
Save
#35 · (Edited)
Well like Matt said, there is no mechanical/technical connection between the Indian of the 1950’s back, to today’s modern “Polaris” Indian.
And many here would agree, today’s Indian’s roots seem to come from the “Victory”. Which Is very logical and not like it’s a bad thing.. It’s just a intuitive, practical continuation of a manufacturing process and business Model.[yuck]
 
#41 ·
Give Matt a break, after all he works for Laidlaw HD. His family owns it. Do you think he would bestow how much better the Indian is compared to a HD? Nope, neither would you if you were in his shoes.

Kinda reminds me of the iPhone (no offense to those that love theirs) apple fan people. But you see brand loyalty to Apple, regardless of who came out with what first. How long did it take for apple to move up from their 3.5" screens. How many appleholics stuck by them the whole way probably still would be. I saw that stupid video Matt made, how dumb. He didn't win anyone on the fence about HD or Indian, all he got was HD fanboys to cheer him on.
 
#42 ·
Why give him a break on what is tantamount to slander? He could've kept his mouth shut and not made an ass of himself (probably impossible for him) and no one would be talking about it. So no, he wouldn't bestow anything on Indian, and had absolutely no reason to even talk about Indian...except that his ego is so fragile that he can't stand to see the competition doing something better than HD.
 
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.