I priced an Indian warranty and the cheapest was almost $2000 with the price going up from there (different dealers, different prices). I also look at several other companies. I ended up going with EFG (less than $900). I bought from Thomas Parker Finance Manager at Imotorsports 630-634-8428. I have had numerous calls with him and his references over on the Can Am Spyder forum (their company sells both brands) were outstanding. He advertises that their warranty prices are the cheapest. They even added a FREE EFG million mile warranty on the powertrain and transmission.
I know several here will say that you have to do all your Mx with them for the million mile engine and transmission add on (not true, you do have to do the oil changes but you can do them yourself as long as you keep records),( you can also do upgrades to your bike but they ask that they be done by an authorized mechanic and not your cousins brothers friend who just bought his first set of tools from the garage sale down the street and he feels he is ready to break down his first ever engine), and that an extended warranty is a waste. Honestly I hope it is and this bike is just like my Yamaha Roadstar where I had ZERO problems except the ones I created myself. However if they are like my wife Hyundai (on which I just bought a extended Hyundai warranty)..I have already used it 3 times this year (any issues I take it to the dealer) and it had already paid for itself. My Indian dealer service department manager and techs have all said that the EFG policy is great for them to use because they have no issues with the company getting authorized to do repairs.
In the end its going to boil down to doing just what you are doing, ask around, and then go with your own thoughts. I personally have never known anyone to complain about an extended warranty except those that didnt read the contract and later said they had no idea it did not cover oil, gas, break pads, or tires that had zero tread life left after using them for over 40K. Yes there are some companies that if you do an engine upgrade, or change pipes, or dont have your local dealer do all of the mx that do not get coverage but you would hear of them and avoid spending your hard earned money with them before hand. I look forward to hearing of your experience with what ever company you decide to go with